Many ‘antidepressant’ drugs on the market today, are prescribed with the intention of increasing levels of active serotonin – the so called ‘happiness hormone’ – circulating in the brain. Unfortunately (and not for biologically inexplicable reasons) they have been associated with increased suicide rates among users. Coffee is protective.
“The FDA admitted in 2007 that SSRIs [selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors] can cause madness at all ages and that the drugs are very dangerous…All patients being treated with antidepressants…should be…observed closely for clinical worsening, suicidality, and unusual changes in behavior…The following symptoms, anxiety, agitation, panic attacks, insomnia, irritability, hostility, aggressiveness, impulsivity, akathisia (psychomotor restlessness), hypomania, and mania, have been reported…”
Coffee seems to act in what could reasonably be described as the opposite direction – improving metabolic function and lowering exposure to serotonin – hence it is probably not a coincidence that regular coffee drinkers are known to have a low incidence of suicide.
“…suicide risk…decreased in a dose-dependent manner with increasing consumption of coffee. As compared with non-coffee drinkers…suicide was 45% lower among individuals who consumed 2–3 cups of coffee per day, and 53% lower among individual consuming ≥4 cups of coffee per day.”
“We conducted a 10-year follow-up study (1980 to 1990) in an ongoing cohort of 86 626 US female registered nurses aged 34 to 59 years…A strong inverse relationship was similarly found for caffeine intake from all sources and risk of suicide…The data suggest a strong inverse association between coffee intake and risk of suicide…”
“Restraint stress…caused a marked increase in dopamine and serotonin (5-HT) levels in the hippocampus…Pretreatment with 33 mg/kg coffee or 1.7 mg/kg caffeine reduced…restraint-induced increase in the neurotransmitters, especially 5-HT…”
Serotonin is closely tied to the regulation of emotion, and excess serotonin has been demonstrated to interfere with thyroid function, reducing metabolic rate, impeding brain function, thereby potentially promoting symptoms of anxiety and depression, including learned helplessness and despair.
Much like the physiological state of hibernation – which occurs in the presence of rising levels of serotonin (as well as suppressed body temperature and brain function) – many of the features of depression go hand in hand with an under performing thyroid energy metabolism.
“Patients affected by subclinical hypothyroidism had a prevalence of depressive symptoms of 63.4%…This study underlines a strong association between subclinical hypothyroidism and depressive symptoms, which could have some important diagnostic and therapeutic implications in the clinical practice.”
In both of these stressful scenarios (i.e. hibernation and depression) there is a shift towards the use of fat as fuel for the cells (away from the metabolism of glucose), similar in many ways to the physiological conditions which lead to blood sugar dysregulation, insulin resistance and diabetes.
In fact, plenty of good evidence exists which shows a relationship between emotional stress, anxiety and diabetes, and there is no shortage of biologically rational explanations for why this makes sense.
“Chronically high anxious arousal and inflammation increase one’s risk of developing type 2 diabetes…Individuals with low inhibition were more likely to have diabetes than those with high inhibition due to the serial pathway from high anxious arousal to IL-6…”
One good rationale is that stress and low blood sugar interfere with thyroid function and energy metabolism, promoting the release of many inflammatory stress substances (such as cortisol, serotonin, nitric oxide and estrogen) implicated in the progression of degenerative conditions including depression and diabetes.
This kind of metabolically suppressed state is more likely to become a persistent or chronic issue, as fat stores become increasingly polyunsaturated. This is due in large part to the many inflammatory, immunosuppressive and thyroid interfering features of the polyunsaturated fats (PUFAs), which are released as free fatty acids into the bloodstream, in larger amounts under conditions of stress.
As well as having powerful anti-thyroid and inflammatory effects, the breakdown products of the PUFAs can increase the harm potential of cortisol, serotonin, nitric oxide and estrogen, encouraging greater interference with metabolic energy production, worsening issues related to proper blood sugar regulation.
Depression and anxiety have been shown to be the result of a hypometabolic state, exacerbated by oxidative stress (resulting from the breakdown products of PUFAs), and directly associated with symptoms of blood sugar dysregulation and diabetes.
Inflammation has been shown to be a factor involved in the progression of mood dysregulation and suicidal thinking and behavior, and caffeine protects against inflammation and oxidative stress.
“…there is a growing body of evidence that inflammation, as manifested by increased levels of pro‐inflammatory cytokines and inflammatory metabolites, is present in patients with suicidal behaviour and ideation…”
Stress and the breakdown of PUFAs increases exposure to bacterial endotoxin, and endotoxin (LPS) directly causes inflammation and interferes with oxidative energy production. Endotoxin is well known to be involved in the progression of metabolic disease, and has been studied in relation to depression and anxiety. Caffeine protects against the inflammatory stress promoting effects of endotoxin.
“In LPS-exposed rats IL-1β and CD68 cell counts both increased at p8 compared to NS controls. These increases in proinflammatory markers were no longer present in caffeinetreated LPS-exposed pups…suggesting a protective effect of caffeine on respiratory function via an anti-inflammatory mechanism.”
It has been demonstrated that the stress hormone cortisol, more commonly promotes depression in men, with estrogen being a stronger driver of depression in women. Experimental evidence continues to show that depression and anxiety is actually a high serotonin state, and caffeine has been shown to reduce serotonin levels, including brain serotonin.
“Corticosteroids may play an important role in the relationship between stress, mood changes and perhaps suicidal behavior by interacting with 5-HT1A receptors. Abnormalities in the HPA axis in response to increased levels of stress are found to be associated with a dysregulation in the serotonergic system, both in subjects with mood disorders and those who engage in suicidal behavior.”
Serotonin promotes cortisol and estrogen, and estrogen induces nitric oxide production. Nitric oxide has been demonstrated to be involved in the progression of anxiety and depression, and is also associated with suicide. Caffeine and some other things found in coffee can lower nitric oxide.
“In recent studies, it has been shown that kahweol, coffee-specific diterpene, exhibit chemoprotective effects…The nitrite production induced by LPS was markedly reduced in a dose-dependent manner…kahweol suppressed the expression of iNOS protein and iNOS mRNA.”
Coffee is known to stimulate thyroid function as well as having been shown to suppress estrogen and cortisol levels, and so it can be seen to be helping with depression and related mood issues on a variety of metabolic fronts.
“Coffee extract blocked 11beta-HSD1-dependent cortisol formation…We suggest that at least part of the anti-diabetic effects of coffee consumption is due to inhibition of 11beta-HSD1-dependent glucocorticoid reactivation.”
An increase in dopamine relative to serotonin is another factor which it has been suggested has antidepressant significance, and there is evidence that caffeine (whilst lowering serotonin) also increases dopamine.
Caffeine assists with the production of the protective hormones pregnenolone and progesterone, and both these substances are protective against depression and anxiety, as well as other mood disorders such as bipolar and schizophrenia. Low pregnenolone production is associated with suicide.
“The study showed that pregnenolone was significantly decreased in the parietal cortex in the combined group of patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder who died by suicide compared with patients with these disorders who died of other causes.”
Caffeine is a non-selective adenosine antagonist, increases cAMP by inhibition of PDE-4, promotes GABA and glutathione, and inhibits parathyroid hormone, and these are also factors involved in protection against mood dysregulation and other metabolic inflammatory conditions.
Coffee and caffeine (much like improved thyroid function) increase body temperature, and whole body hyperthermia has been used successfully to treat depression.
“The internal temperature started to increase after both treatments, but became slightly different 2 h after caffeine consumption. Mean skin temperature after caffeine consumption increased, and became significantly different compared to the control treatment after 90 min…”
Caffeine increases metabolic rate and promotes the production of mitochondria, and it is not by coincidence that mitochondrial dysfunction is involved in the progression of mood dysregulation. As with any substance that stimulates metabolism however, caffeine increases the amount of glucose which is able to be used by the cells.
“From our data we gather that caffeine stimulates metabolism and favorable mitochondrial production…Our findings support the advertised metabolic benefits of caffeine, making it a potential contributor in humanity’s struggle against obesity.”
When sufficient sugar is not consumed with coffee (especially if glycogen stores are low as a result of stress) this can result in an increase in the release of adrenalin and cortisol (as a means to sourcing out an alternative fuel supply), turning what is able to be a mood stabilizing (as well as enhancing) disease protective food, into something potentially stress increasing and anxiety promoting.
As well as stimulating cortisol and adrenalin, the consumption of too much coffee relative to energy availability, can lead to a rise in other stress substances like serotonin, nitric oxide and estrogen, and can also promote the release of the polyunsaturated free fatty acids, worsening stress and inflammation.
In this sense, consuming lots of coffee without the accompaniment of plenty of fuel, can create the impression that coffee per se is harmful and responsible for a worsening of metabolic issues.
Many of the experiments showing negative aspects of coffee or caffeine have been designed without taking these factors into consideration, and often use unnaturally high doses, leading to results which are highly misleading and unhelpful.
Regular consumption of coffee combined with a sufficient intake of sugar is known to protect against many inflammatory conditions including liver disease, diabetes, MS, Parkinson’s, cardiovascular disease and cancer.
“High versus low coffee consumption was associated with a lower risk of prostate cancer, endometrial cancer, melanoma, oral cancer, leukaemia, non-melanoma skin cancer, and liver cancer. For prostate, endometrial, melanoma, and liver cancer there were also significant linear dose-response relations indicating benefit.”
The ability of coffee or caffeine to protect against depression and suicide, is most likely also directly connected to the liver protective (and healing) impact of regular coffee consumption, as a well functioning liver is important for proper thyroid function and for protection against systemic exposure to the inflammatory stress substances, including estrogen and endotoxin. Sufficient intake of sugar and protein are fundamental to good liver function.
A diet removing PUFA and limiting intake of difficult to digest grains, seeds, nuts, beans and lots of under cooked vegetable matter, with sufficient protein from milk, cheese and gelatin, and plenty of sugar from sweet fruits, fruit juice, white sugar and honey, is one good way to improve liver function, lower inflammation, and help to get the benefits from regular coffee (and other caffeinated drink) consumption.
Some other things that can help improve metabolism, liver function and mood issues include aspirin, niacinamide, glycine, K2, methylene blue, thiamine, vitamin E, taurine, activated charcoal and cyproheptadine.
Ironically, sensitivity to coffee has been shown to be an effective measure of liver damage.
Are you consuming enough sugar with your coffee?
For those who are super sensitive to the effects of coffee, one thing that has been known to work, is to start by introducing it gradually, consuming small amounts combined with milk and sugar or with meals.